The Ethical Demise of Sovereign Grace Ministries (Part 1)
Wednesday, August 1, 2012 at 4:50PM
Brent Detwiler

The ethical demise of SGM has broken my heart more than any other aspect of its decline.  It has been excruciating to watch close friends lie and deceive in order to preserve their image and notoriety.  Is so doing, they have ruined a godly movement with their duplicity.  By trying to save their reputations, they have destroyed their reputations.  

At every turn over the past 13 months, C.J., Dave Harvey, and others have sought to preserve their reputations instead of their integrity.  This truth is evident to thousands of people whose trust has been lost.  In this post and my next one, I’ve compiled the fifty most egregious lies told by SGM.  This list could be much longer and I find no pleasure in saying so.  If I added all the lies of SGM leaders it would number in the hundreds with no exaggeration.  I have spent 3 weeks researching and writing this material.  

Everything you are about to read is factual in nature.  That is the sad truth.  I realize some people have a hard time coming to terms with this reality.  I did too.  It took a long time before I was forced to accept the harsh reality that friends like C.J. and Dave were so willing to mislead, break promises, and lie in order to advance their own self-interests.  It stills seems unbelievable to me.  These were men I once trusted but that trust is broken.  Only a fool trusts in men who have continually proven themselves untrustworthy and that without sorrow.  When you lose your integrity, you lose your soul. 

These Top 50 lies were all brought up but in no case did that effort result in repentance or confession by the appropriate person(s).  I also asked for rebuttals but none were supplied.  These illustrations are presented in context and supported by evidence.  I could easily add more references if I took additional time for discovery.  Therefore, I am not slandering or sinfully judging.  Broken promises are treated as lies because they represent sacred commitments regarding crucial matters that were violated without warning or discussion.  

As we begin, I am reminded of James’ exhortation, “Weep, mourn and wail” (4:9).  I still hope that happens with SGM leaders.  It is one reason for my ongoing efforts and willingness to present these charges to objective evaluators in a just setting.  Counting down…      

50. C.J. promising to reveal his salary.  

Reference:  The Need for an Independent Board of Directors & Financial Accountability

49. Tommy Hill pledging that Ambassadors of Reconciliation would deal with the specific issue of making known C.J.’s salary and benefits.      

Reference:  The Need for an Independent Board of Directors & Financial Accountability

48. C.J. covering up the real reason for wanting to take his son Chad on a trip to Phoenix. 

Reference:  A Final Appeal (pp. 19-20)

47. C.J. lying to Gene Emerson about why he could not speak at a regional Celebration conference (i.e., Revive) and a regional marriage conference. 

Reference:  Response Regarding Friendship and Doctrine (p. 99)

46. C.J. claiming he would make it easy for apostolic team if we asked him to step down.  

Reference:  Response Regarding Friendship and Doctrine (pp. 49-53)

45. C.J. deceiving me into thinking he did not give my notes from our November 2004 meeting to Bob Kauflin and Kenneth Maresco. 

Reference:  Response Regarding Friendship and Doctrine (pp. 38-45, 66-67)

44. C.J. saying he lessened my responsibilities in SGM due to a lack of capacity and gifting when it was due to offenses with me.

References:  Response Regarding Friendship and Doctrine (pp. 69-74); A Final Appeal (pp. 61-62)

43. C.J. and Jeff Purswell lying about the reason I was removed from teaching in the Pastors College.  

Reference:  Response Regarding Friendship and Doctrine (pp. 122-125)

42. Dave denying the existence of his private letter to C.J. confronting him on the breakdown in our relationships on the apostolic team due to C.J.’s pride and especially his harsh treatment of me.

References:  Response Regarding Friendship and Doctrine (p. 90); A Final Appeal (pp. 85-87)

41. Dave Harvey saying there was 98% agreement between Joshua Harris and the interim Board when Joshua stepped down as a Director.

40. John Loftness and the new Board saying the main reasons for relocating SGM to Louisville was its central location (untrue) and lower cost of living (true).

Reference: Sovereign Grace Ministries Relocation Announcement

39. C.J. leading the CLC pastors to believe he was starting an accountability group on his own initiative having gone without one for three years when in reality he began the group in response to our directive as an apostolic team.

Reference:  Response Regarding Friendship and Doctrine (p. 18)

38. C.J. lying about his accountability to the pastors of Covenant Life Church and the amount of input he was receiving from them. 

References:  The Three Years Trying to Help C.J. (Dec. 2000 to Dec. 2003); A Final Appeal (p. 118)

37. C.J. concealing from the CLC pastors three years of input and correction he received from the apostolic team and other leaders.  

References:  The Three Years Trying to Help C.J. (Dec. 2000 to Dec. 2003);  Response Regarding Friendship and Doctrine (pp. 9-15)

36. C.J. telling Dave, Steve and me, that Pat had no concerns for his leadership or heart when he abruptly and unilaterally decided to cancel New Attitude contrary to our counsel.

Reference:  A Final Appeal (pp. 54-56)

35. C.J. saying the CLC pastors disagreed with the apostolic team’s assessment of his character when in fact they agreed with our assessment.

Reference:  Response Regarding Friendship and Doctrine (pp. 16-28)

34. C.J. lying on multiple occasions when he promised the apostolic team he would update the CLC pastors on input we were giving him.  He did the same thing with the CLC pastors.  He’d promised to update the apostolic team on their input but then concealed it from us.

Reference:  Response Regarding Friendship and Doctrine (pp. 61-65, 87)

33. Jeff Purswell claiming C.J. “fully apprised” the Board of Directors of all his sins against Larry Tomczak. 

32. Dave characterizing my documents as a “sad tale” and his version of events since January 2010 as a “faithful narrative” in a secret letter to the SGM pastors intended to discredit me behind my back. 

Reference:  The Mona Lisa of Spin by Master Harvey

31. Dave, Joshua and Jeff saying their sending out of this secret letter would be evaluated.

Reference:  The Mona Lisa of Spin by Master Harvey

30.  Dave Harvey and the interim Board misrepresenting my reasons for initially turning down the proposal for the Adjudication Hearing last October and refusing to post my actual explanation.

Reference:  The Right of Tyrants; Another Illustration of Dave Harvey’s Deceit

29. Dave and the interim Board concealing from the public my eager desire to meet with C.J. and the reasonable conditions I set forth for such a meeting. 

References:  The Mona Lisa of Spin by Master Harvey; A Final Appeal (p. 75)

28. The interim Board posting that I refused to participate in mediation until after C.J. published an extensive response to every one of my charges. 

Reference:  Liar, Liar, Pants on Fire; The Five Resolutions – July 13, 2011; Concluding Remarks (pp. 4-9)

27. The interim Board posting that I refused to participate in mediation until after C.J. made a public confession.  

References:  Liar, Liar, Pants on Fire; The Five Resolutions – July 13, 2011

26. Promising to confess sins publicly and follow the recommendations from Ambassadors of Reconciliation. 

References:  Why I’m taking a leave of absence; Liar, Liar, Pants on Fire; The Five Resolutions – July 13, 2011

##

Stephen Covey says the following in his best-selling book, The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People.

“Integrity includes but goes beyond honesty.  Honesty is telling the truth—in other words, conforming our words to reality.  Integrity is conforming reality to our words—in other words, keeping promises and fulfilling expectations.”  (pp. 195-196)

Dishonesty and broken promises are the habits of highly defective leaders.  In this regard, Proverbs 10:9 is extremely instructive.  It reads, “He who walks in integrity walks securely, but he who perverts his ways will be found out.” 

From the advent of computers to email to the internet to social networking, I have always given full and complete access to my wife in all these venues.  She can review anything I’ve written, read, viewed, received or sent no matter how personal.  Why?  Because I have nothing to hide.  I live securely not fearing I’ll be exposed by anything she discovers.  The same should be true in every facet of our lives.   

C.J., Dave, and so many other leaders in SGM have lived some part of the past 8 years doing all in their power to avoid being exposed and to prevent SGM from being exposed.  During this period of time, I’ve sought to bring patterns of sinful living or ministering into the light especially related to C.J.  That effort has been weighty but in comparison my burden has been lite.  Here’s what I mean.  I could not bear up under the constant dread of being exposed and living before a holy God with a guilty conscience. 

When you live in integrity you are not looking over your shoulder and you don’t live with frayed nerves.  You have confidence before God and men.  C.J., Dave and others have spent the past 13 months exhausting their energies covering up iniquity and doing damage control.  I continue to pray God will have mercy upon their souls and lead them to repentance. 

Psalm 32:4-5 For day and night your hand was heavy upon me; my strength was sapped as in the heat of summer.  Selah  [5] Then I acknowledged my sin to you and did not cover up my iniquity.  I said, “I will confess my transgressions to the Lord” — and you forgave the guilt of my sin.

To be continued.

##

##

Please Help - All Gifts & Tax Deductible Contributions Are Kept Strictly Confidential

Article originally appeared on (http://www.brentdetwiler.com/).
See website for complete article licensing information.